print | Send to a Friend | Bookmark and Share

Our Spicy Thanksgiving


Thanksgiving in our household had its own spicy twist.

As Indians, who had emigrated to the United States, the whole concept of turkeys, pilgrims, football, apple pie, and Native Americans with feathers in their hair seemed quite foreign to my parents.

But over time, the day began to hold a lot of meaning and significance.  It represented a time to recognize all that they could be grateful for - health, family, success, and happiness.  My parents and many of our relatives welcomed family members who would come to Boston from around the country for the gathering.  A huge feast was planned for the day, including masala turkey, spicy Indian vegetable filling, and traditional Indian potatoes on the side.  Dessert was a combination of apple pies, brownies, and traditional Indian dessert.  Bollywood music played in the background, while my brother and other cousins dragged our elders to the television and tried to explain the game of football to them.  After genuinely trying to understand the game for a few minutes, the adults would quickly lose interest and drift outside to play cricket.

My memories of Thanksgiving mark in an important lesson in how I want to celebrate holidays with my children.  We live in a multicultural society where we marry people of other cultures, from different backgrounds, with different ideologies and religious beliefs.  Our holidays and customs build the foundation for how we identify ourselves and who we are connected.  While Sumant (my husband) identifies himself as an Indian, I identify myself as Indian American.  How will my children identify themselves?  Is there a need for them to identify themselves in a mutlicultural society?

I have struggeld with whether or not to get a Christmas tree.  We are not Christian, so why would we celebrate the holiday? (When we were young, my parents would buy us one gift each, and hang up a stocking by the fireplace.  Christmas was not about gifts, but it became a day we learned about giving.)  At the same time, I do not want my young children to feel excluded from the dominant society.  I want them to know the Indian festivals like Diwali (the festival of light that marks the New Year) and Hole (the festival of color).  But I also want them to understand the traditions and holidays of their friends - from Ramadan to Id to Hanukah and the Chinese Moon Festival.

In a world of so much color and flavor, perhaps the answer is to create a calendar of holidays that we celebrate throughout the year.  This calendar is full of rich traditions, color, stories, and most of all connections - bonds with your heritage, world, self and the friends and families you love.

(This is an excerpt from my book, 100 Promises to My Baby.)

Comments (21)
Philosopher's picture
Posted by Brian Johnson
Love it. New Year's is my favorite. I aim to celebrate it every morning as I journal and then end my yoga practice with shivasana--dying to the old self and being born again into the new! :) -bri
Chatterjee's picture
Posted by V C Chatterjee
Yes Mallika, I fully appriciate your view. I am an Indian in India, Hindu philosophy has taught me and my family to respect all other religion and culture. This has given me a wider range of opportunity to understand, appriciate and enjoy others' point of view. Though my knoledge of Thanks Giving is limited, we take keen interest in celeberting Christmas, to mark the day when tiny little Juses came to us ! My thirteen year son takes the lead role in this...
RuthWhiteHawkMurray's picture
Posted by Ruth Murray
I don't really celebrate any special holiday for myself...I do go to gatherings on Thanksgiving, Christmas, and Easter for others...but my own idea of my favorite holiday(holy day) are three days in my life that God gave to me...the day of my birth, which I hold sacred as God's gift to my parents and me, the day of my daughter's birth which, to me, is God's gift to her, her father and I, and the day that I started to massage, which to me is God's gift to me that I get to share with others. They might not be holidays for others, but they are special sacred days for me.
gidge72's picture
Posted by Stephanie Stackenwalt
I am still looking at what traditions I want to create with my family. I believe that celebrating everyday as a gift, and to be grateful for that gift. However, I want to teach my children to be open to other cultures and their beliefs, to find their own spirituality by trying what beliefs best suit them, and to find beauty in everything. Like I began with this comment, I am still looking and being open to new ideas.
Anonymous's picture
Posted by deniseheyse (not verified)
nice malika- a family culture built around celebration and inclusion- !
KAN's picture
Posted by Kurt Nimphius
For most folks in America Christmas is the Holiday of Holidays, and rightly so, what a joyous day of giving, family gatherings, smiley faces, great food and great music. You don
kyilmaz's picture
Posted by Ken Yilmaz
Thanksgiving and Christmas
Mr.McGoo's picture
Posted by Tim Douglas
My favourite holidays are Christmas, Easter and Thanksgiving. An interesting conversations and discussion, inspring faith in the inclusive belief that there are many roads and paths leading us home to our Creator, the Truth, the Light and the Source of all Life; regardless of what our religious beliefs, leanings or dis-belief may be. It really is all about virtue, respect, giving to the needy, praying for the needy and playing love forward at every opportunity. ENJOY, ENJOY, ENJOY, ... THE JOURNEY WHEREVER AND WHENEVER IT TAKES YOU!!!
meadysmusings's picture
Posted by Babita Dubay
Growing up in Trinidad where both Christmas and Diwali are public holidays I've always asked myself which one I liked better...Diwali became a public holiday here in the 60's and so has been a public holiday my entire life...it was always a big family festival but in the mid 80's started to grow as a big national festival as well. And so has been a national do since my teens as well. Whilst Christmas was always big for us as a nation as it was inherited from our colonial times on the island and the island was predominantly run by Catholic conventions. Many of my relatives were instrumental in that shift (Diwali becoming more national) and I myself used to do Indian folk dance when younger at festivities nationwide and have since been involved at the high school-although I attended a Presbyterian one and the festivities then were only marked as a formality although the majority of the student body at the top school were Hindu...that must have changed by now too but you can't blame a religious body for wanting to promote their religion at a school partly funded by them. And then I participated at a university and now my company level...and more and more I try to figure out which festival I like more?... When I was younger I more saw Diwali as holier time cause here people fast (non vegetarians dont eat meat for weeks starting off from the Nav Ratri -Durga festival) and the pooja rituals etc is a big deal. Being vegetarian I normally only eat fruits on the day before the pooja which I often sit for...or sometimes only drink water. So think when I was younger I more saw Christmas as the less religious one where was gift giving (cause here we dont do the diwali gift exchange much and even hindus do that more for christmas) and even more eating but less religious relevance as I'm officially Hindu and my family is and not Christian. I don't think I can decide though more so that through the years I've even really gotten into the religious aspect of Christmas too (seeing Jesus as a point of light in the universe...infact it is why I feel so affected by Easter since in my teens too)...for the past few yrs I've wanted to attend the Catholic Mass that Catholic Christians have here (I later found out that independently my mum and two brothers have had this desire too!) But so far for a billion reasons have not attended such a Mass. Perhaps I will this year? As a whole I think throughout my life way before I created the blog have been contemplating this thing call Universal Collective Prayer so...I've even tried to understand bout festivals not celebrated on my island especially since there is a vast world out there off it and beyond my Indo-Hindu roots too. So I've often wondered bout the North American Thanksgiving... on one hand I cant handle the mass killings of the poor turkeys on this day and especially in this age of multiculturalism...well cant we see the light and share peace and love with our dear brothers and sisters ...our feathered friends too? But of course people eat meat year round too...but I find Thanksgiving and Christmas so focusses around the bird in the centre as if it is a worship of the bird perhaps an animal sacrifice? And for sure this (animal sacrifice) is done literally in the Muslim festival of Eid Ul Addah no? But on the other hand the idea of family gatherings and a gathering to give thanks at that is so lovely...too bad done over a bird. Hence if I was American or had to celebrate Thanksgiving I'd think it lovely and do so but over a vege meal as so many are planning here at the Intent community from all I've been reading about. I guess the idea is you can embrace all religions and mulitculturalism as long as it does not clash with your core values whatever they may be and the idea is for all of us to respect that of the other...tolerance when we can't have acceptance...so as I can't understand the animals eating similarly I understand when non-Hindus (for instance) might not be able to accept some of my stuff... Happy and Blessed Holidays to All! Maybe we all will be able to truly sit in Universal Collective Prayer one day...
meadysmusings's picture
Posted by Babita Dubay
On a totally lighter note my bday is on what we inherited from the Brits here in Trinidad as Boxing Day and it is a public holiday too! So I think that sweetens the pot for Christmas :) Not only my bday but two holidays always back to back...giving way to long weekends depending on how they fall...I think on the whole holidays here were initially set up along the Catholic lines and then started to evolve with time so interesting mix...but even though we as a result ended up having one of the highest holiday counts on earth! :) I think it was always tough to take out the traditional Catholic ones too cause it had become so ingrained into the culture and so is why the holiday counts just kept going up and up as other groups got recognition. Like Easter weekend is a big thing on the neighbouring island of Tobago and Good friday and Easter Mon is a holiday here too(to cater for Sun which is always a holiday also Christian in origin) And so one yr it was bantered about that we could remove easter monday as it didnt stand for anything religious but it had to be kept as it would tamper with the whole social, cultural and economic dynamic that goes on over easter weekend especially in Tobago with races and all of that...but the Catholic Whit Monday did lose its head though...I still havent a clue why it was a holiday so I guess it's why...
ppp90's picture
Posted by lisa germain
halloween my favrite holiday becase i like to decarate the house windows.
sal's picture
Posted by Sal Kydd
Christmas is my favorite. It has so many warm memories for me and is a holiday so rich in traditions and history. I am very sentimental and love the idea of Santa, leaving him cookies, decorating the tree, the smell of mince pies and mulled wine! Sigh! I'm not religious per se at all, but for me it's not about that. It's about celebrating our family and our culture. I'm a Brit so Thanksgiving doesn't have that same resonance. I enjoy it - but am sure it's meaning will grow for me the longer I spend here.
gregory57's picture
Posted by Greg Kirk
Mallika: I thought about your question while swimming laps at lunch today. I love all religious holidays, especially holy days in the Jewish and Islamic calendars - Hanukah especially touches a chord of hope within me, one of my most cherished possessions is a Menorah given to me by a close, deceased friend who was a Rabbi in life. As I learn about Diwali, I find that celebrations that are new to me touch me deeply too. Like Kurt, Christmas and Easter are two very special days in my life, partly, because I have celebrated them all of my life and partly, because of their universal nature. I reflected especially on the celebration of Christmas as honoring the archetype of the Christ. It is a holiday that holds truth for everyone: His birth, your birth, my birth, everyone's birth was truly "miraculous" - life is a miracle in itself. Surely angelic tongues vibrated with "peace on earth" and "goodwill to humankind" at our birth too - one of the reasons your father's request for vows of non-violence has touched me so deeply is because I believe our deepest and truest nature includes our being born with a compassionate and loving self - embracing the vow is coming to "remember" who we truly are. Surely that was cause for great celebration. The Christian Scripture's myth story of the Magi (Wise Men) bearing gifts to the Christ child was the Evangelist's way of promoting the universal recognition of the divinity of Jesus - as your father has eloquenty written, those same seeds of divinity are planted within us too! Finally, in the myth, Jesus was born in a stable because there was no room for him, he lay in a feeding trough. What has the birth story myth to do with us? I believe it teaches us that God is always, in a very special way, on the side of the marginalized, the outcasts, the lonely and despised among us. Our task is to comfort God living in those individuals and to work for justice and change so that everyone can live with dignity. The feeding trough bed - all of us are meant to become "food" for others, we must open ourselves and be willing to share the essence of who we are, our talents, our gifts, our energy - in order to discover who we truly are. Thank you for a great question. I hope you and your family have a warm and wonderful Thanksgiving holiday. Love, Greg
Krissy's picture
Posted by Krissy Saunders
Mallika, I am not Christian, but we celebrate Christmas with a tree filled with gifts underneath. It is my opinion that children can be taught about giving within this, and in other ways throughout the year. I feel bad for the kids who don't get to experience the MAGIC of Santa, the reindeer, the sleigh, the elves, etc. My gift back (not that I need or expect one) is their excitement of putting carrots out for the reindeer and cookies for Santa, and barely being able to fall asleep they are so fired up. And then waking up at the crack of dawn to see them jump around and squeal in joy at something they were hoping to get that they'd received. Kids live in a world of innocence and they will learn soon enough it wasn't real, and what the true meaning of giving at this time means. I had a tree every year growing up with lots of goodies and presents (these are some of my favorite memories), etc, even though my parents were Atheists, yet I have dedicated my life to giving back to the world what I've been given. I didn't learn to give from my parents, but from within. Even though my parents were Atheists, they wanted us to be able to enjoy this experience even though money was tight and there were 9 of us. I had zero idea that Christmas was the birth of Christ or any of that until I grew up and started reading about it. I was sheltered from it if you want to call it that. My 2 boys are huge givers, and give toys to charity every year. We have a rule, which my kids remind me of, that when a new gift comes in no matter the time of year, they need to choose one for charity. They love this, and look forward to giving. Some argue that we are teaching dishonesty to our kids by 'lying' about Santa, but COME ON...lol, this is taking ourselves a little tooooooo seriously. Your kids will forgive and understand this little white lie when the time comes. My older boy, Lukas, is 9.5 years old and this may be his last year believing in the magic of Santa, which brings tears to my eyes. I love hearing my boys talk about Santa, and watching them write their lists, and to think this is going to end soon breaks my heart. My advice is to indulge them in this time, you will all benefit. I'm not sure who derives more pleasure from Santa...them or me :)
linda.larue's picture
Posted by Linda LaRue
Mallika, my hands down favorite holiday is Thanksgiving. For me Thanksgiving is a quiet time to reflect about the past year life then, giving gratitude to those folks who have given to me. This year I have been blessed with the success of Crunchless Abs. I am eternally grateful to the great team at Savvier. Plus, this is the biggest eating holiday of the year. I love to cook and have guests enjoy themselves. Maybe this year I'll serve something a little spicy in honor of your beautiful blog! Linda LaRue, RN MEd, ATC
meadysmusings's picture
Posted by Babita Dubay
Hey Greg we must share similar interests in the Magi then! :) Check out my blog on it if you like: http://universalcollectiveprayer.blogspot.com/2008/11/we-three-kings-mys...
meadysmusings's picture
Posted by Babita Dubay
And Mallika...btw I know I'm writing a million comments on here! :) But my family also historically has a tendency to play cricket during our christmas retreat as I like to call it cause we have at least two days back to back with boxing day being off too! Growing up I used to join in the matches too...less cricket as we are an ageing bunch now and not that many new borns! :) Of course Trinidad and the rest of what makes up the test playing identity known as the West Indies got cricket like India from the Brits... I plan to blog more into the Christmas season bout Trinidad's Christmas traditions and in particular bout parang music which I hold as synonymous with a 'Trini Christmas' something that we share in common with other places with some Spanish influence...hoping to get an interview with a Venezuelan 'oil' colleague who I understand is from the area in Venezuela it's similar to here in Trinidad of course not an actual musician but someone who at least will know bout the place. And perhaps I'll be able to flag down a singer-parandero or two as well...will see...blogging can be such fun at times!:)
scribehermes's picture
Posted by Usha Sivaranjani Sista
Dear Mallika I should say that your question has brought home the fact that I have lost interest in holidays. Maybe that is a side-effect of growing 'old'. Well, I am only 25 but I appear to have lost most of the interest in life and adventures. Holidays were special when I was in school. Festivals were the only time my brother and I used to get new clothes. We used to play to our heart's content with our friends and eat all that moms made. I guess I am trying to rekindle that spirit for the sake of my 6-month old daughter, Tvisha. I live in Sydney. This is a multicultural city. Vivek (my husband) and I are planning to buy a Christmas tree this year and invite some kids home for tea. The idea to bring children together at a time when playing with cousins is almost a lost concept. We want to introduce Tvisha to playing with other children and watch them share things (hopefully!). We want to create a home where children love to come. Holidays are the best time for that. I never realized parenting could be so tough and so much fun until I became a parent myself. What ideas do all of you have? Love Usha
meadysmusings's picture
Posted by Babita Dubay
Here I go posting again:) But had to say it ...Usha you are only 25! How on earth can you be saying you have grown old...even though you put it as 'old' I felt really sad to read that you at 25 have lost most of your interest in life and adventures! I immediately had this vision of me jumping up and grabbing each of your hands in each of mines and pulling you up to dash off and play with me! :) It's quite the opposite for me...I often feel society will think me weird since I'll be 34 this holidays...on Boxing day and still single...and truly single not divorced and now single or had one of those 'things' just like marriage and now single...I've always been single! In my 20s it used to be a time when well another year and my family might be asking bout well when...but into my 30s it just doesnt matter anymore! The only thing is I worry that society will come and tell me my time is up...and that Im too 'old' for real this time and I should stop playing the video games with the kids and this and that...I mean esp when I can no longer past for a 20something even by a long shot! And my parents are gone and I'm suppose to be like...But thing is I'd still want to be playing except society as I said might bleep me out! After all I won't be a child anymore. I always say I have a kinda Peter Pan Syndrome in a sense except I pay the bills and stuff too...and really am not afraid to grow up just a child at heart? But it's quite the opposite worry huh?! I think in your case as your child gets older you might find yourself discovering your inner child again through her...just wait till she is 5 or so...:) I think that happens with many adults and then there are the ones like me who never grew up in the first place! :( / :) - societal misfit perhaps? But really you should never lose your sense of adventure! Hope your young daughter rekindles that in you as she grows up! :) And perhaps I'll find a playmate that is closer to my age one of these days! :)
gregory57's picture
Posted by Greg Kirk
Babita: Thanks for sharing with me that you had written a post on the Magi - I enjoyed it! The Magi do appear in Scripture: in the Hebrew Scriptures, the author notes that Pharoh had advisors known as "wise men." In the Christian Scriptures, the story of the Magi following the star, their encounter with King Herod and their bearing gifts to the universal child are found in Matthew's Gospel. Thanks again. Love, Greg
Dave's picture
Posted by Dave Trager
Mind as well do whatever would be the most fun for you and your family. I am jewish (technically speaking), but I get a christmas tree, and even believed in santa when I was little, since my mom's side is catholic. (Dad's side is jewish) The santa part I think is horrible lol, I would never lie to a child like that- it is too crushing when you find out the truth. ;) But I do enjoy getting into the spirit of things! Sounds like your parents handled it nicely. :)